Did you know we buy certified BullionPLUS marketed coins?

Vintage Numismatics

Our offers for NGC/PCGS certified vintage numismatics typically range between 80% and 110% of the Greysheet price guide. Actual offers may vary (higher or lower) depending on current market demand and the specific coin in question.

If you’re interested in selling BullionPLUS-certified vintage numismatics—from bag labels to our other premier products—please reach out to us using our contact form.

Due to updated policies on platforms such as WhatNot, we are unable to provide public-facing offers directly through our e-commerce website.

Modern Numismatics

For NGC/PCGS certified modern collectibles, we generally make purchase offers 120–180 days after product release. Because these items are often limited and exclusive, market values may fluctuate significantly in the early months.  Slab quality must be new condition.

As our modern products grow and feature limited mintages, we allow time for the market to stabilize before issuing firm offers.

Sealed Mystery Products

We do not write offers on sealed mystery products.

Payment Terms

Once your products have been received and checked for quality, we issue a physical check via mail issued by our parent company, Dempsey & Baxter, LLC.  No other form of payment will be issued.  You must include a copy of our emailed offer to you inside the package along with your shipping and driver's license information.